Thermal conductivity against densityHigher and further left: spreads more heat for its weightThermal expansion against thermal conductivityLower and further right: warps less when heated
Try it on a partA bracket to run stress or thermal on, free in your browser
Sources7 documents: UltiMaker, American Institute of Steel Construction, bauforumstahl (ArcelorMittal), Covestro, Ovako
FDM Polycarbonate
Ultimaker PC, 3D-printed specimens, XY (flat); Ultimaker S5 Pro, engineering intent profile, 0.15 mm layer height, AA 0.4 print core, 100% infill, Cura 4.9, printed one-at-a-time, conditioned >=24 h at room temperature. TDS (file v5.00), April 20, 2022.
Steel A992
ASTM A992 W-shapes; Fy/Fu specified minimums from AISC publications (AISC 360-16 Commentary; Modern Steel Construction); elastic constants AISC 360; physical constants from the bauforumstahl structural-steel EPD, which names A992 among covered product standards.
1
Ultimaker PC Technical Data Sheet, v5.00UltiMakerarchived copyFDM Polycarbonate · Yield strength: typicalFDM Polycarbonate · Ultimate tensile strength: typical, peak stress (= stress at yield)FDM Polycarbonate · Flexural strength: typicalFDM Polycarbonate · Elongation at break: typicalFDM Polycarbonate · Young's modulus (stiffness): typicalFDM Polycarbonate · Density: rangeFDM Polycarbonate · Glass transition: typicalFDM Polycarbonate · Max service temperature: HDT 0.455 MPa (printed specimens)
2
Updating Standard Shape Material Properties Database for Design and ReliabilityAmerican Institute of Steel Constructionarchived copySteel A992 · Yield strength: typical: mean of 20,295 A992 flange mill-test coupons (1998 SSPC survey), as reported by AISCSteel A992 · Ultimate tensile strength: typical: mean of 20,295 A992 flange mill-test coupons (1998 SSPC survey)Steel A992 · Elongation at break: typical: mean of 24,847 A992 mill-test elongations, web and flange (1998 SSPC mill data), as reported by AISC
3
ANSI/AISC 360-16 Specification for Structural Steel Buildings, with CommentaryAmerican Institute of Steel Constructionarchived copySteel A992 · Young's modulus (stiffness): design value (AISC 360-16)Steel A992 · Poisson's ratio: design value (AISC 360-16 Commentary)
4
Environmental Product Declaration: Structural Steel Sections and Merchant Bars (2023)bauforumstahl (ArcelorMittal)archived copySteel A992 · Density: nominal (constructional data)Steel A992 · Thermal conductivity: nominal at 20 °CSteel A992 · Thermal expansion: nominal (constructional data, no temperature range stated)
5
Engineering Polymers Part and Mold Design: Thermoplastics, A Design GuideCovestroarchived copyFDM Polycarbonate · Poisson's ratio: base material: polycarbonate family typical (Covestro Part and Mold Design guide, Table 3-1)
6
Makrolon 2405 Technical Data SheetCovestroFDM Polycarbonate · Thermal conductivity: base material: Covestro Makrolon 2405 injection-molding PC, typical, through-plane, 23 °CFDM Polycarbonate · Thermal expansion: base material: Covestro Makrolon 2405 injection-molding PC, typical, 23-55 °C, parallel
7
S275JR Steel GradeOvakoSteel A992 · Specific heat: base material: EN S275JR unalloyed structural steel (the EN counterpart of A36), typical, 50/100 °C
Each number points to the document that states it, with the exact basis. Values without a number are computed from the sourced ones. "Not sourced" means no citable source states it (or only a specification minimum); figures computed from it are left out too.
FDM Polycarbonate is 3D printed: its properties depend on build direction and print settings; these are typical values.
Questions
Mechanical
Is FDM Polycarbonate stronger than Steel A992?
Steel A992 is stronger: its yield strength is 385 MPa against 53.3 MPa for FDM Polycarbonate (7.22x).
Which is lighter, FDM Polycarbonate or Steel A992?
FDM Polycarbonate is lighter: 1,190 kg/m³ against 7,850 kg/m³ for Steel A992.
Which is stiffer, FDM Polycarbonate or Steel A992?
Steel A992 is stiffer: Young's modulus 200 GPa against 2.39 GPa for FDM Polycarbonate, so the same part in Steel A992 deflects less under the same load.
Which is lighter for the same job, FDM Polycarbonate or Steel A992?
For the same stiffness or strength: FDM Polycarbonate is lighter for a stiff panel or plate, strong beam, strong panel or plate; Steel A992 is lighter for a stiff rod or tie (tension), stiff beam (bending), strong rod or tie.
Part that must be
FDM Polycarbonate
Steel A992
Stiff rod or tie (tension)
12.7x heavier
lighter
Stiff beam (bending)
39% heavier
lighter
Stiff panel or plate
lighter
1.51x heavier
Strong rod or tie
9% heavier
lighter
Strong beam
lighter
1.77x heavier
Strong panel or plate
lighter
2.45x heavier
For the same stiffness or strength, mass scales with density over stiffness (or strength) raised to a power set by how the part is loaded: 1 for a rod in tension, 1/2 for a beam in bending, 1/3 for a panel (the standard material-selection indices).
Which is more ductile, FDM Polycarbonate or Steel A992?
Steel A992 stretches further before it breaks: 24.2% elongation at break against 9.2% for FDM Polycarbonate.
Thermal
Which conducts heat better, FDM Polycarbonate or Steel A992?
Steel A992 conducts heat better: 48 W/m·K against 0.2 W/m·K for FDM Polycarbonate.
Which expands less with temperature?
Steel A992 expands less: 12 µm/m·K against 65 µm/m·K for FDM Polycarbonate.